My favorite pizza in the city. A large Hilda's Favorite hits the spot every time. The West Portal location has a few tables but if the weather is nice just take it and find a breezy spot to sit. Service is fast because we always order online ahead of time and it's never cold when we get there at the estimated ready time.

Good pizza! Small place and perfect for a quick slice. I was super hungry and just needed something to hold me off until dinner time and goat hill pizza saved the afternoon. I really enjoyed the bbq chicken pizza. Adding dried red peppers gave it a nice kick. My partner got the veggie pizza and it was cheesy and soft. The best part was the crust! I'm not a crust person, but I think their crust was made with sourdough bread. So good! It was just crunchy enough and just chewy enough. The next time I'm in this part of town, I'll be ordering more than just a slice! Yum!

We decided to get a pizza today. I had some points to redeem and my birthday treat which made the XL special combo $15 which included the soon to be eliminated junk fee of health mandate and tax. The pizza was ordered by phone but by the time we got it home, parts were soggy not the delish crispy crust I've had here before. Staff was very nice. Can not wait to order again.

First time having Goat Hill Pizza and I must say I was happy I tried it! The pizza was on the thinner side which is how I like it and had a sourdough crust which was great! Would definitely get it again!

We've been ordering from West Portal Goat Hill for years, but something amazing has happened to it post-pandemic. It's the same sourdough crust and huge pizza slices for walk-in (and they'll sell whole pies to go if you want), but it's the friendly service and this nice, scrubbed "eat-in-if-you-want" feeling. We bought several slices on a prime-time Friday and *gasp*, there were many delish choices! And THANK you employees for really being sweet and nice and friendly. Attention Meat-eaters, I HIGHLY Recommend this Porky Pie - Ham/bacon, roasted garlic, red onion, garlic, and some magic. Seriously, I usually don't eat "ham", but this was the bomb. Topped off by great counter service at take-out. Thanks, Goat Hill, for being a dependable West Portal favorite after all these years.

The quality of the pizza itself was delicious! The sourdough taste and texture of the bread was an added bonus to their options of traditional and seasonal pizzas. I had the previlege of trying both today and they were SPECTACULAR! One pizza was made of chicken, bacon, garlic sauce, and fresh sage and lemon slices; and who could go wrong with pepperoni pizza? I was blown away at the creativity of the first pizza. I just would have never though to put fresh lemon slices and fresh sage onto my pizza, but oh boy, the saying, "Never judge a book by its' cover" never was so true! I would love to come back again if I am in the area. Pleased and satisfied.